Euthanasia and the good life: why euthanasia is (sometimes) ethical

Česká verzia

Authors: David Černý
Authors place of work: Kabinet zdravotnického práva a bioetiky Ústavu státu a práva AV ČR, v. v. i., Praha
Published in the journal: Vnitř Lék 2018; 64(3): 236-244
Category: Reviews

Summary

In this paper I present the strongest argument, in my opinion, in favour of moral admissibility of euthanasia. In the introduction I briefly mention two important arguments in support of euthanasia – out of respect for autonomy and as a last act of grace, however I refuse them as insufficient. I propose a definition of both forms of assisted death: euthanasia and assisted suicide. I present the basic ideas underlying the theory of the good life and deal with hedonism in greater depth. I define a deprivation concept of the badness of death and, employing hedonism, I specifically describe when death is bad and when it is good. Next I present consequentialism and utilitarianism and show how it is possible to proceed from the reflections on the good life and badness of death toward the concrete normative conclusions about euthanasia. In conclusion I extend my reflections also to other theories of the good life, such as preferentialism or the theory of objective desire and the objective pluralistic theory. The paper arrives at the defense of the thesis that there exist situations in medical practice in which euthanasia presents a morally acceptable choice.

Key words:
concept of badness of death – consequentialism – deprivation – desire-fulfilment theory – euthanasia – hedonism – preferentialism – utilitarianism

Zdroje

1. Young R. Medically Assisted Death. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge (UK) 2007. ISBN 978–0521880244.

2. Velleman D. Against the Right to Die. J Med Philos 1992; 17(6): 665–681.

3. Tännsjö T (ed). Terminal Sedation: Euthanasia in Disguise? Springer: Dordrecht 2004. ISBN-13: 978–9048165940.

4. Doležal A. Eutanazie a rozhodnutí na konci života. Právní aspekty. Academia: Praha 2017. ISBN 978–80–200–2687–3.

5. Hříbek T. Obrana asistované smrti: Filozofické argumenty ve prospěch eutanazie a asistovaného usmrcení za pomoci lékaře. Academia: Praha 2018. V tisku.

6. Kuře J. Co je eutanazie: Studie k pojmu dobré smrti. Academia: Praha 2017. V tisku.

7. Friedlander H. The Origins of Nazi Genocide. From Euthanasia to the Final Solution. 3rd ed. The University of North Carolina Press: Chapel Hill & London 1995. ISBN 978–0807822081.

8. Haškovcová H. Lékařská etika. 4 vyd. Galén: Praha 2015. ISBN 978–80–7492–204–6.

9. Miller FG, Truog RD. Death, Dying, and Organ Transplantation. Reconstructing Medical Ethics at the End of Life. Oxford University Press: New York 2012. ASIN: B01FGK1EW6.

10. Černý D. Je ukončení život udržující léčby eutanazií? In: Humeník I, Szaniszló, IM, Zoláková Z (eds). Právné otázky rozhodovania v onkologické starostlivosti. Wolters Kluwer: Bratislava 2015: 133–152. ISBN 978–80–8168–185–1.

11. Sumner LW. Assisted Death. A Study in Ethics and Law. Oxford University Press: New York 2011. ISBN 978–0199607983.

12. Sumner LW. Welfare, Happiness, and Ethics. Clarendon Press: Oxford (UK) 1996. ISBN 978–0198244400.

13. Bradley B. Well-Being. Polity: Malden (USA) 2015. ISBN 978–0745662732.

14. Fletcher G. The Philosophy of Well-Being. Routledge: London and New York 2016. ISBN 978–1138818354.

15. Feldman F. Pleasure and Good Life. Concerning the Nature, Varieties, and Plausibility of Hedonism. Oxford University Press: Oxford (USA) 2004. ASIN: B01F9GP158.

16. Crisp R. Reasons and the Good. Oxford University Press: Oxford (USA) 2008. ISBN 978–0199548699.

17. Kagan S. Death. Yale University Press: New Haven and London 2012. ISBN 978–0300180848.

18. Walton D. On Defining Death. An Analytic Study of the Concept of Death in Philosophy and Medical Ethics. McGill-Queen’s University Press: Montreal 1979. ISBN 978–0773503311.

19. Rosenberg JF. Thinking Clearly About Death. 2nd ed. Hackett Publishing Company: Indianapolis 1998. ISBN 978–0872204263.

20. Belshaw C. Annihilation. The Sense and Significance of Death. McGill-Queen’s University Press: Montreal & Kingston 2009. ISBN 978–0773535527.

21. Laertios Díogenés. Životy, názory a výroky proslulých filosofů. 2. ed. Nová tiskárna: Pelhřimov 1995: 419. ISBN 80–901916–3-0.

22. Feldman F. Confrontations with the Reaper. A Philosophical Study of the Nature and Value of Death. Oxford University Press: New York 1992. ASIN: B01FIZ4746.

23. Luper S. The Philosophy of Death. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge (UK) 2009. ISBN-10: 0521709121. ISBN-13: 978–0521709125.

24. Bradley B. Well-Being & Death. Oxford University Press: New York 2011. ISBN-10: 0199596255. ISBN-13: 978–0199596256.

25. Fischer JM (ed). The Metaphysics of Death (Stanford Series in Philosophy). Stanford University Press: Stanford 1993. ISBN 978–0804721042.

26. Driver J. Consequentialism (New Problems of Philosophy). Routledge: New York 2012. ISBN 978–0415772587.

27. Rachels J. The End of Life: Euthanasia and Morality (Studies in Bioethics). Oxford University Press: New York 1986. ISBN 978–0192177469.

28. Oderberg DS. Moral Theory. A Non-Consequentialist Approach. Blackwell: Malden 2000. ISBN 978–0631219033.

29. Finnis J. Moral Absolutes. Tradition, Revision, and Truth (Michael J. Mcgivney Lectures of the John Paul II Institute). The Catholic University of America Press: Washington, D.C. 1991. ISBN 978–0813207452.

30. Singer P. Practical Ethics. 3rd ed. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge 2011. ISBN 978–0521707688.