Surgery Versus Epilation for the Treatment of Minor Trichiasis in Ethiopia: A Randomised Controlled Noninferiority Trial
Background:
Trachomatous trichiasis can cause corneal damage and visual impairment. WHO recommends surgery for all cases. However, in many regions surgical provision is inadequate and patients frequently decline. Self-epilation is common and was associated with comparable outcomes to surgery in nonrandomised studies for minor trichiasis (<six lashes touching eye). This trial investigated whether epilation is noninferior to surgery for managing minor trichiasis.
Methods and Findings:
1,300 individuals with minor trichiasis from Amhara Regional State, Ethiopia were recruited and randomly assigned (1∶1) to receive trichiasis surgery or epilation. The epilation group were given new forceps and epilation training. The surgical group received trichiasis surgery. Participants were examined every 6 months for 2 years by clinicians masked to allocation, with 93.5% follow-up at 24 months. The primary outcome measure (“failure”) was ≥five lashes touching the eye or receiving trichiasis surgery during 24 months of follow-up, and was assessed for noninferiority with a 10% prespecified noninferiority margin. Secondary outcomes included number of lashes touching, time to failure, and changes in visual acuity and corneal opacity.
Cumulative risk of failure over 24 months was 13.2% in the epilation group and 2.2% in the surgical group (risk difference = 11%). The 95% confidence interval (8.1%–13.9%) includes the 10% noninferiority margin. Mean number of lashes touching the eye was greater in the epilation group than the surgery group (at 24 months 0.95 versus 0.09, respectively; p<0.001); there was no difference in change in visual acuity or corneal opacity between the two groups.
Conclusions:
This trial was inconclusive regarding inferiority of epilation to surgery for the treatment of minor trichiasis, relative to the prespecified margin. Epilation had a comparable effect to surgery on visual acuity and corneal outcomes. We suggest that surgery be performed whenever possible but epilation be used for treatment of minor trichiasis patients without access to or declining surgery.
Trial registration:
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT00522912
: Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summary
Vyšlo v časopise:
Surgery Versus Epilation for the Treatment of Minor Trichiasis in Ethiopia: A Randomised Controlled Noninferiority Trial. PLoS Med 8(12): e32767. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001136
Kategorie:
Research Article
prolekare.web.journal.doi_sk:
https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1001136
Souhrn
Background:
Trachomatous trichiasis can cause corneal damage and visual impairment. WHO recommends surgery for all cases. However, in many regions surgical provision is inadequate and patients frequently decline. Self-epilation is common and was associated with comparable outcomes to surgery in nonrandomised studies for minor trichiasis (<six lashes touching eye). This trial investigated whether epilation is noninferior to surgery for managing minor trichiasis.
Methods and Findings:
1,300 individuals with minor trichiasis from Amhara Regional State, Ethiopia were recruited and randomly assigned (1∶1) to receive trichiasis surgery or epilation. The epilation group were given new forceps and epilation training. The surgical group received trichiasis surgery. Participants were examined every 6 months for 2 years by clinicians masked to allocation, with 93.5% follow-up at 24 months. The primary outcome measure (“failure”) was ≥five lashes touching the eye or receiving trichiasis surgery during 24 months of follow-up, and was assessed for noninferiority with a 10% prespecified noninferiority margin. Secondary outcomes included number of lashes touching, time to failure, and changes in visual acuity and corneal opacity.
Cumulative risk of failure over 24 months was 13.2% in the epilation group and 2.2% in the surgical group (risk difference = 11%). The 95% confidence interval (8.1%–13.9%) includes the 10% noninferiority margin. Mean number of lashes touching the eye was greater in the epilation group than the surgery group (at 24 months 0.95 versus 0.09, respectively; p<0.001); there was no difference in change in visual acuity or corneal opacity between the two groups.
Conclusions:
This trial was inconclusive regarding inferiority of epilation to surgery for the treatment of minor trichiasis, relative to the prespecified margin. Epilation had a comparable effect to surgery on visual acuity and corneal outcomes. We suggest that surgery be performed whenever possible but epilation be used for treatment of minor trichiasis patients without access to or declining surgery.
Trial registration:
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT00522912
: Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summary
Zdroje
1. MariottiSPPascoliniDRose-NussbaumerJ 2009 Trachoma: global magnitude of a preventable cause of blindness. Br J Ophthalmol 93 563 568
2. WestESMunozBImeruAAlemayehuWMeleseM 2006 The association between epilation and corneal opacity among eyes with trachomatous trichiasis. Br J Ophthalmol 90 171 174
3. BurtonMJKintehFJallowOSillahABahM 2005 A randomised controlled trial of azithromycin following surgery for trachomatous trichiasis in the Gambia. Br J Ophthalmol 89 1282 1288
4. BurtonMJBowmanRJFaalHAryeeEAIkumapayiUN 2006 The long-term natural history of trachomatous trichiasis in the Gambia. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 47 847 852
5. ReacherMHMunozBAlghassanyADaarASElbualyM 1992 A controlled trial of surgery for trachomatous trichiasis of the upper lid. Arch Ophthalmol 110 667 674
6. World Health O 2006 Trachoma control - a guide for programme managers Geneva World Health Organization
7. BowmanRJFaalHJattaBMyattMFosterA 2002 Longitudinal study of trachomatous trichiasis in The Gambia: barriers to acceptance of surgery. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 43 936 940
8. World Health Organization 2004 Report of the 2nd global scientific meeting on trachoma Geneva World Health Organization
9. BerhaneYWorkuABejigaA 2006 National survey on blindness, low vision and trachoma in Ethiopia Addis Ababa Federal Ministry of Health of Ethiopia
10. LewallenSMahandeMTharaneyMKatalaSCourtrightP 2007 Surgery for trachomatous trichiasis: findings from a survey of trichiasis surgeons in Tanzania. Br J Ophthalmol 91 143 145
11. HabtamuERajakSNGebreTZerihunMGenetA 2011 Clearing the backlog: trichiasis surgeon retention and productivity in northern Ethiopia. PLoS Negl Trop Dis 5 e1014 doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0001014
12. CourtrightP 1994 Acceptance of surgery for trichiasis among rural Malawian women. East Afr Med J 71 803 804
13. OlivaMSMunozBLynchMMkochaHWestSK 1997 Evaluation of barriers to surgical compliance in the treatment of trichiasis. Int Ophthalmol 21 235 241
14. MahandeMTharaneyMKirumbiENgirawamunguEGeneauR 2007 Uptake of trichiasis surgical services in Tanzania through two village-based approaches. Br J Ophthalmol 91 139 142
15. BowmanRJSomaOSAlexanderNMilliganPRowleyJ 2000 Should trichiasis surgery be offered in the village? A community randomised trial of village vs. health centre-based surgery. Trop Med Int Health 5 528 533
16. ReacherMFosterAHuberJ 1993 Trichiasis surgery for trachoma: the bilamellar tarsal rotation procedure Geneva World Health Organization
17. World Health Organization 2005 Final assessment of trichiasis surgeons Geneva World Health Organisation
18. BurtonMJBowmanRJFaalHAryeeEAIkumapayiUN 2005 Long term outcome of trichiasis surgery in the Gambia. Br J Ophthalmol 89 575 579
19. KhandekarRMohammedAJCourtrightP 2001 Recurrence of trichiasis: a long-term follow-up study in the Sultanate of Oman. Ophthalmic Epidemiol 8 155 161
20. WestESMkochaHMunozBMabeyDFosterA 2005 Risk factors for postsurgical trichiasis recurrence in a trachoma-endemic area. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 46 447 453
21. BowmanRJFaalHMyattMAdegbolaRFosterA 2002 Longitudinal study of trachomatous trichiasis in the Gambia. Br J Ophthalmol 86 339 343
22. MeleseMWestESAlemayehuWMunozBWorkuA 2005 Characteristics of trichiasis patients presenting for surgery in rural Ethiopia. Br J Ophthalmol 89 1084 1088
23. RajakSNHabtamuEWeissHABedriAGebreT 2011 Epilation for trachomatous trichiasis and the risk of corneal opacification. Ophthalmology In press
24. DawsonCRJonesBRTarizzoML 1981 Guide to trachoma control Geneva World Health Organization
25. ThyleforsBDawsonCRJonesBRWestSKTaylorHR 1987 A simple system for the assessment of trachoma and its complications. Bull World Health Organ 65 477 483
26. WestSKWestESAlemayehuWMeleseMMunozB 2006 Single-dose azithromycin prevents trichiasis recurrence following surgery: randomized trial in Ethiopia. Arch Ophthalmol 124 309 314
27. LeeAHWangKScottJAYauKKMcLachlanGJ 2006 Multi-level zero-inflated poisson regression modelling of correlated count data with excess zeros. Stat Methods Med Res 15 47 61
28. WoretaTAMunozBEGowerEWAlemayehuWWestSK 2009 Effect of trichiasis surgery on visual acuity outcomes in Ethiopia. Arch Ophthalmol 127 1505 1510
Štítky
Interné lekárstvoČlánok vyšiel v časopise
PLOS Medicine
2011 Číslo 12
- Statinová intolerance
- Očkování proti virové hemoragické horečce Ebola experimentální vakcínou rVSVDG-ZEBOV-GP
- Co dělat při intoleranci statinů?
- Pleiotropní účinky statinů na kardiovaskulární systém
- DESATORO PRE PRAX: Aktuálne odporúčanie ESPEN pre nutričný manažment u pacientov s COVID-19
Najčítanejšie v tomto čísle
- Violent Crime, Epilepsy, and Traumatic Brain Injury
- Rotating Night Shift Work and Risk of Type 2 Diabetes: Two Prospective Cohort Studies in Women
- Surgery Versus Epilation for the Treatment of Minor Trichiasis in Ethiopia: A Randomised Controlled Noninferiority Trial
- Worldwide Incidence of Malaria in 2009: Estimates, Time Trends, and a Critique of Methods