Medical Evidence of Human Rights Violations against Non-Arabic-Speaking Civilians in Darfur: A Cross-Sectional Study

English version České info

Background:
Ongoing conflict in the Darfur region of Sudan has resulted in a severe humanitarian crisis. We sought to characterize the nature and geographic scope of allegations of human rights violations perpetrated against civilians in Darfur and to evaluate their consistency with medical examinations documented in patients' medical records.

Methods and Findings:
This was a retrospective review and analysis of medical records from all 325 patients seen for treatment from September 28, 2004, through December 31, 2006, at the Nyala-based Amel Centre for Treatment and Rehabilitation of Victims of Torture, the only dedicated local provider of free clinical and legal services to civilian victims of torture and other human rights violations in Darfur during this time period. Among 325 medical records identified and examined, 292 (89.8%) patients from 12 different non-Arabic-speaking tribes disclosed in the medical notes that they had been attacked by Government of Sudan (GoS) and/or Janjaweed forces. Attacks were reported in 23 different rural council areas throughout Darfur. Nearly all attacks (321 [98.8%]) were described as having occurred in the absence of active armed conflict between Janjaweed/GoS forces and rebel groups. The most common alleged abuses were beatings (161 [49.5%]), gunshot wounds (140 [43.1%]), destruction or theft of property (121 [37.2%]), involuntary detainment (97 [29.9%]), and being bound (64 [19.7%]). Approximately one-half (36 [49.3%]) of all women disclosed that they had been sexually assaulted, and one-half of sexual assaults were described as having occurred in close proximity to a camp for internally displaced persons. Among the 198 (60.9%) medical records that contained sufficient detail to enable the forensic medical reviewers to render an informed judgment, the signs and symptoms in all of the medical records were assessed to be consistent with, highly consistent with, or virtually diagnostic of the alleged abuses.

Conclusions:
Allegations of widespread and sustained torture and other human rights violations by GoS and/or Janjaweed forces against non-Arabic-speaking civilians were corroborated by medical forensic review of medical records of patients seen at a local non-governmental provider of free clinical and legal services in Darfur. Limitations of this study were that patients seen in this clinic may not have been a representative sample of persons alleging abuse by Janjaweed/GoS forces, and that most delayed presenting for care. The quality of documentation was similar to that available in other conflict/post-conflict, resource-limited settings.

: Please see later in the article for the Editors' Summary

Vyšlo v časopise: Medical Evidence of Human Rights Violations against Non-Arabic-Speaking Civilians in Darfur: A Cross-Sectional Study. PLoS Med 9(4): e32767. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001198
Kategorie: Research Article
prolekare.web.journal.doi_sk: https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1001198

Souhrn

Zdroje

1. MullinsCWRotheDL 2007 The forgotten ones: the Darfuri genocide. Crit Criminol 15 135 158

2. FlintJDe WaalA 2005 Darfur: a short history of a long war London Zed Books

3. HertzkeAD 2005 The shame of Darfur. First Things 156 16 22

4. StrausS 2005 Darfur and the genocide debate. Foreign Aff 84 123 133

5. US Department of State 2004 Documenting atrocities in Darfur. State publication 11182 Washington (District of Columbia) Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor and the Bureau of Intelligence and Research, US Department of State

6. Office of UN Deputy Special Representative of the UN Secretary General for Sudan, UN Resident and Humanitarian Co-ordinator 2008 Darfur humanitarian profile no. 30 Khartoum United Nations

7. NabarroD 2004 Mortality projections for Darfur Geneva World Health Organization

8. HaganJRymond-RichmondWParkerP 2005 The criminology of genocide: the death and rape of Darfur. Criminology 43 525 561

9. US Government Accountability Office 2006 Darfur crisis: death estimates demonstrate severity of crisis, but their accuracy and credibility could be enhanced Washington (District of Columbia) US Government Accountability Office

10. McCarthyBHaganJ 2009 Counting the deaths in Darfur: pitfalls on the pathway to a public sociology. JeffriesV Handbook of public sociology Lanham Rowman and Littlefield Publishers 319 337

11. DepoortereEChecchiFBroilletFGerstlSMinettiA 2004 Violence and mortality in West Darfur, Sudan (2003–04): epidemiological evidence from four surveys. Lancet 364 1315 1320

12. GrandessoFSandersonFKruijtJKoeneTBrownV 2005 Mortality and malnutrition among populations living in South Darfur, Sudan: results of 3 surveys, September 2004. JAMA 293 1490 1494

13. ChecchiFRobertsL 2008 Documenting mortality in crises: what keeps us from doing better. PLoS Med 5 e146 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0050146

14. HaganJPalloniA 2006 Social science. Death in Darfur. Science 313 1578 1579

15. DegommeOGuha-SapirD 2010 Patterns of mortality rates in Darfur conflict. Lancet 375 294 300

16. LeaningJ 2004 Diagnosing genocide—the case of Darfur. N Engl J Med 351 735 738

17. VanRooyenMJLeaningJJohnsonKHirschfeldKTullerD 2008 Employment of a livelihoods analysis to define genocide in the Darfur region of Sudan. J Genocide Res 10 343 358

18. LeaningJ 2007 The crime of genocide. BeyrerCPizerHF Public health and human rights Baltimore The Johns Hopkins University Press 202 221

19. PowellCL 2004 The crisis in Darfur. Testimony before the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee, September 9, 2004 Washington (District of Columbia) US Department of State

20. SsenyonjoM 2010 II. The International Criminal Court arrest warrant decision for President Al Bashir of Sudan. Int Comp Law Q 59 205 225

21. International Criminal Court 2009 Warrant of arrest for Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir. ICC-02/05-01/09 The Hague International Criminal Court

22. International Criminal Court 2010 Second warrant of arrest for Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir. ICC-02/05-01/09 The Hague International Criminal Court

23. TottenSMarkusenE 2005 The U.S. government Darfur genocide investigation. J Genocide Res 7 279 290

24. HaganJRymond-RichmondWPalloniA 2009 Racial targeting of sexual violence in Darfur. Am J Public Health 99 1386 1392

25. HaganJRymond-RichmondW 2008 The collective dynamics of racial dehumanization and genocidal victimization in Darfur. Am Sociol Rev 73 875 902

26. Physicians for Human Rights 2009 Nowhere to turn: failure to protect, support and assure justice for Darfuri women Cambridge Physicians for Human Rights and Harvard Humanitarian Initiative

27. Physicians for Human Rights 2006 Darfur: assault on survival: a call for security, justice and restitution Cambridge Physicians for Human Rights

28. Buchanan-SmithMJasparsS 2007 Conflict, camps and coercion: the ongoing livelihoods crisis in Darfur. Disasters 31 Suppl 1 S57 S76

29. US Department of Health and Human Services 2004 Guidelines for the conduct of research involving human subjects at the National Institutes of Health Washington (District of Columbia) US Department of Health and Human Services

30. United Nations High Commissioner on Human Rights 1999 Manual on the effective investigation and documentation of torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment New York United Nations

31. PeelMIacopinoV 2002 The medical documentation of torture London Greenwich Medical Media

32. IacopinoV 2008 Model curriculum on the effective medical documentation of torture and ill-treatment Copenhagen International Rehabilitation Council for Torture Victims

33. ZarocostasJ 2009 Expulsion of 13 relief agencies from Darfur could devastate health care. BMJ 338 b985

34. BasogluMLivanouMCrnobaricC 2007 Torture vs other cruel, inhuman, and degrading treatment: is the distinction real or apparent? Arch Gen Psychiatry 64 277 285

35. SollomRRichardsAKParmarPMullanyLCLianSB 2011 Health and human rights in Chin State, Western Burma: a population-based assessment using multistaged household cluster sampling. PLoS Med 8 e1001007 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001007

36. HougenHP 1988 Physical and psychological sequelae to torture. A controlled clinical study of exiled asylum applicants. Forensic Sci Int 39 5 11

37. MollicaRFWyshakGLavelleJ 1987 The psychosocial impact of war trauma and torture on Southeast Asian refugees. Am J Psychiatry 144 1567 1572

38. MollicaRFCaspi-YavinYBolliniPTruongTTorS 1992 The Harvard Trauma Questionnaire. Validating a cross-cultural instrument for measuring torture, trauma, and posttraumatic stress disorder in Indochinese refugees. J Nerv Ment Dis 180 111 116

39. HollifieldMEckertVWarnerTDJenkinsJKrakowB 2005 Development of an inventory for measuring war-related events in refugees. Compr Psychiatry 46 67 80

40. MollicaRFCaspi-YavinY 1991 Measuring torture and torture-related symptoms. Psychol Assess 3 581 587

41. IacopinoVXenakisSN 2011 Neglect of medical evidence of torture in Guantanamo Bay: a case series. PLoS Med 8 e1001027 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001027

42. ForrestD 1995 The physical after-effects of torture. Forensic Sci Int 76 77 84

43. GoldfeldAEMollicaRFPesaventoBHFaraoneSV 1988 The physical and psychological sequelae of torture. Symptomatology and diagnosis. JAMA 259 2725 2729

44. BoehnleinJKKinzieJD 1995 Refugee trauma. Transcult Psychiatry 32 223 252

45. WeinsteinHMDanskyLIacopinoV 1996 Torture and war trauma survivors in primary care practice. West J Med 165 112 118

46. CohenJ 1960 A coefficient of agreement for nominal scales. Educ Psychol Meas 20 37 46

47. Humanitarian Information Centre for Darfur 2005 South Darfur field atlas Khartoum Humanitarian Information Centre for Darfur

48. Humanitarian Information Centre for Darfur 2005 West Darfur field atlas Khartoum Humanitarian Information Centre for Darfur

49. Humanitarian Information Centre for Darfur 2005 North Darfur field atlas Khartoum Humanitarian Information Centre for Darfur

50. SlocumTA 1999 Thematic cartography and visualization Upper Saddle River Prentice Hall

51. SwissSGillerJE 1993 Rape as a crime of war. A medical perspective. JAMA 270 612 615

52. AmowitzLLReisCLyonsKHVannBMansarayB 2002 Prevalence of war-related sexual violence and other human rights abuses among internally displaced persons in Sierra Leone. JAMA 287 513 521

53. KivlahanCEwigmanN 2010 Rape as a weapon of war in modern conflicts. BMJ 340 c3270

54. MullinsCW 2009 “He would kill me with his penis”: genocidal rape in Rwanda as a state crime. Crit Criminol 17 15 33

55. GingerichTLeaningJ 2004 The use of rape as a weapon of war in the conflict in Darfur, Sudan Washington (District of Columbia) Office of Transition Initiatives, US Agency for International Development

56. KellyJKabangaJCraginWAlcayna-StevensLHaiderS 2011 ‘If your husband doesn't humiliate you, other people won't’: gendered attitudes towards sexual violence in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo. Glob Public Health 7 285 298

57. United Nations 1998 United Nations: Rome statute of the International Criminal Court [adopted July 17, 1998]. Int Legal Mat 37 999 1069

58. Eboe-OsujiC 2007 Rape as genocide: some questions arising. J Genocide Res 9 251 273

59. Médecins Sans Frontières 2005 The crushing burden of rape: sexual violence in Darfur Amsterdam Médecins Sans Frontières

60. MorenoAIacopinoV 2008 Forensic investigations of torture and ill-treatment in Mexico. A follow-up study after the implementation of the Istanbul Protocol. J Leg Med 29 443 478

61. FrickeALKhairA 2007 Laws without justice: an assessment of Sudanese laws affecting survivors of rape Washington (District of Columbia) Refugees International

62. Human Rights Watch 2008 Five years on: no justice for sexual violence in Darfur New York Human Rights Watch

63. United Nations High Commissioner on Human Rights 2005 Access to justice for victims of sexual violence Geneva Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights

64. KossMP 1993 Detecting the scope of rape: a review of prevalence research methods. J Interpers Violence 8 198 222

65. AskinKD 2006 Prosecuting gender crimes committed in Darfur: holding leaders accountable for sexual violence. TottenSMarkusenE Genocide in Darfur: investigating the atrocities in the Sudan New York Routledge 141 160

66. EllsbergMHeiseLPenaRAgurtoSWinkvistA 2001 Researching domestic violence against women: methodological and ethical considerations. Stud Fam Plann 32 1 16

67. WattsCZimmermanC 2002 Violence against women: global scope and magnitude. Lancet 359 1232 1237

68. Amnesty International 2004 Sudan, Darfur: rape as a weapon of war—sexual violence and its consequences London Amnesty International

69. MorenoAGrodinMA 2000 Photo/essay: the not-so-silent marks of torture. JAMA 284 538

70. McDermottMFLenhardtROCatramboneCDWalterJWeissKB 2006 Adequacy of medical chart review to characterize emergency care for asthma: findings from the Illinois Emergency Department Asthma Collaborative. Acad Emerg Med 13 345 348

71. LuckJPeabodyJWDresselhausTRLeeMGlassmanP 2000 How well does chart abstraction measure quality? A prospective comparison of standardized patients with the medical record. Am J Med 108 642 649

72. PeabodyJWLuckJGlassmanPDresselhausTRLeeM 2000 Comparison of vignettes, standardized patients, and chart abstraction: a prospective validation study of 3 methods for measuring quality. JAMA 283 1715 1722

73. DresselhausTRPeabodyJWLeeMWangMMLuckJ 2000 Measuring compliance with preventive care guidelines: standardized patients, clinical vignettes, and the medical record. J Gen Intern Med 15 782 788

74. JewkesRChristofidesNVettenLJinaRSigsworthR 2009 Medico-legal findings, legal case progression, and outcomes in South African rape cases: retrospective review. PLoS Med 6 e1000164 doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1000164

75. Observatory for the Protection of Human Rights Defenders 2007 Steadfast in protest: annual report 2006 Paris International Federation for Human Rights

76. FowlerJ 2006 Defending human rights and rebuilding with dignity Washington (District of Columbia) US Holocaust Memorial Museum

77. International Committee of the Red Cross 2011 Health care in danger: making the case Geneva International Committee of the Red Cross